I Hate Hating You
Text: Matthew 18:21-35 (with Ephesians 4:31-32 and Colossians 3:12-14)
Opening
There’s a particular kind of tired that sleep doesn’t fix. It comes from carrying someone around in your head: the replayed conversation, the speech you’ll never give, the flinch when their name comes up, the way a song or a street or a holiday can drag them back into the room.
And somewhere in the middle of all that, you catch yourself, maybe in the car, maybe at 3 a.m., and you think: I hate that I hate you.
You didn’t want this. You didn’t sign up to be bitter. You used to be a more generous person than this. And now you’re watching yourself rehearse arguments in the shower and feeling a small, ugly satisfaction when something goes wrong for them. Then the shame arrives: Is this who I’ve become?
If that’s you this morning, hear this: you are not a bad Christian. You are a wounded one. The very fact that the hatred bothers you is evidence that something in you is still resisting it. A heart that’s truly gone hard doesn’t grieve over being hard. Yours is grieving. That’s grace already at work.
So let’s look at what Jesus says to people carrying this weight.
1. The question behind Peter’s question
Peter comes to Jesus with what he thinks is a generous offer. “Lord, how often will my brother sin against me, and I forgive him? As many as seven times?”
Seven was already generous. The rabbis taught three. Peter is doubling it and adding one for good measure. But notice what he’s really asking: Where’s the limit? When do I get to stop? Underneath that is something every one of us understands: How long do I have to keep absorbing this?
Jesus answers, “Not seven times, but seventy-seven times” (or seventy times seven, depending on your translation). The point isn’t that on offense number 78 you’re free to snap. The point is that Jesus is smashing the calculator. Forgiveness isn’t a transaction with a quota. It’s a posture, a way of living.
And then, because Jesus knows we’ll say “but you don’t understand what they did,” he tells a story.
2. The servant who was forgiven everything
A king decides to settle accounts. A servant is brought in who owes him ten thousand talents. A single talent was roughly twenty years of a laborer’s wages. Ten thousand talents is a number so absurd it’s almost comic. It’s more than the entire annual tax revenue of the region. Jesus is describing a debt that cannot be paid in a thousand lifetimes.
The servant falls on his knees and says, “Be patient with me, and I will pay you everything.” Which is ridiculous. He couldn’t. And the king, moved with compassion, does something no one expected: he doesn’t restructure the loan. He doesn’t give an extension. He cancels it. All of it. Gone.
Now watch what happens next. That same servant walks out the door, finds a fellow servant who owes him a hundred denarii, about three months’ wages. Real money, a real wrong, but a tiny fraction of what he’d just been forgiven. And he grabs the man by the throat and says, “Pay what you owe.”
The man falls down and says the exact same words: “Be patient with me, and I will pay you.” The same words the first servant had just spoken to the king. And he refuses. He throws the man in prison.
Here’s what I want you to see: the first servant didn’t forgive because he never actually received his forgiveness. He heard the words, he took the benefit, but it never sank in. He walked out of that throne room still living like a man who owed everything and had to protect himself.
When we can’t forgive, it’s often not because the offense is too big. It’s because we’ve never let ourselves feel how much we’ve been forgiven.
3. Unforgiveness is bookkeeping
Look at what the unforgiving servant was doing. He had a ledger. He was keeping accounts. And that’s exactly what bitterness is: bookkeeping.
We keep a ledger on the person who hurt us. Every entry is accurate. What they said. What they did. What they didn’t do when we needed them. And we hold that ledger, waiting for payment: an apology, an acknowledgment, a little suffering on their side, some proof that they know what they did.
But here’s the problem. They may never pay. They may not even know they owe. They may be sleeping fine tonight, and you’re the one awake doing the math.
Now look at the end of the parable. Who ends up in jail? The servant who wouldn’t forgive. Jesus says he was handed over to the jailers until he should pay all his debt. Unforgiveness doesn’t imprison the one who wronged us. It imprisons us. We become the jailer and the prisoner, guarding a cell that has our own name on it.
The old saying is that resentment is like drinking poison and waiting for the other person to get sick. It’s worn out from overuse, but it’s worn out because it’s true.
4. What forgiveness is not
Before we go further, we have to clear up what forgiveness is not, because many of us resist it for the wrong reasons.
Forgiveness is not pretending it didn’t hurt. Jesus never called evil fine. The king in the parable didn’t say the debt was imaginary. He acknowledged it, and then he bore the cost himself. Forgiveness begins with honesty about the wound.
Forgiveness is not reconciliation. Forgiveness takes one person. Reconciliation takes two. You can forgive someone who’s never apologized, who’s no longer in your life, or who has died. Rebuilding trust is a separate process, and trust must be earned. If someone remains dangerous to you, forgiving them does not mean handing them the keys again. Boundaries and forgiveness are not enemies.
Forgiveness is not a feeling. You may forgive someone and still feel the sting for months. You may wake up Tuesday having forgiven on Monday and find the anger back at the door. That doesn’t mean it didn’t work. Forgiveness is a decision your will makes, and your emotions follow behind, often slowly, like a tired dog trailing its owner.
Forgiveness is not excusing. You can only forgive what was truly wrong. If it were no big deal, there’d be nothing to forgive. Forgiveness says: this was real, this was wrong, and I am releasing you from owing me for it.
So what is it? Forgiveness is the decision to cancel the debt, to close the ledger, to release the person from your courtroom and hand the case over to God, who is a far better judge than you or I will ever be. “Vengeance is mine,” says the Lord. Not because he doesn’t care about justice, but because he’s the only one who can hold it without being poisoned by it.
5. You can only give what you’ve received
Look at the order in Paul’s words to the Ephesians: “Be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as God in Christ forgave you.” And in Colossians: “Bear with one another and, if one has a complaint against another, forgive each other; as the Lord has forgiven you, so you also must forgive.”
Paul doesn’t say try harder. He says remember.
We try to forgive from an empty tank. We scrape together willpower, we grit our teeth, we say the words, and nothing in us moves. Paul says to start somewhere else. Start at the cross. That’s where you were the debtor with the impossible bill, and it was paid, not waived or overlooked, but paid, in full, in blood.
Think about the ten thousand talents. Your sin against a holy God isn’t a small clerical error. It’s a debt you could never have settled. And yet the King came down, and he did not merely cancel the debt; he absorbed it into himself. Every time we sin, he does it again. Every day, mercy is new.
The more deeply you know how much you’ve been forgiven, the less the debt against you weighs. This is the secret. Forgiveness flows downhill from the cross. You are not the source. You are a channel. You don’t have to manufacture mercy; you only have to stop blocking the flow.
6. Practical steps for the person who’s stuck
So what do you do on Monday morning, when the hatred is still there?
Name it honestly to God. Not the polished version. The real one. The Psalms are full of people telling God exactly how furious they are. He can handle it. He’d rather have your honest rage than your polite distance.
Name the debt specifically. Vague forgiveness is easy to fake. What exactly did they take? Respect? Years? Safety? Say it out loud. Then say: “I cancel this debt. I release them from owing me for it.” You may have to say it daily for a season.
Refuse to rehearse. Every time you replay the scene, you’re pulling the ledger back off the shelf. When the thought comes, don’t fight it with shame; redirect it with a short prayer. “Lord, I’ve given this to you. Take it again.”
Pray for them. Jesus said to pray for those who persecute you, and it’s not because it’s easy. Something shifts when you ask God to bless someone you’d rather curse. You can’t keep hating someone you’re sincerely praying for, at least not at the same intensity. Start with something small: God, do for them what you did for me.
Get help if it’s heavy. Some wounds are too deep to work through alone. A pastor, a counselor, a trusted friend: there is no shame in that. Sometimes the church is the hands God uses.
Be patient with yourself. You are on a journey, not at a finish line.
Closing
Maybe you can’t say “I forgive you” yet. Maybe you don’t even want to. Then start smaller. Start with the prayer that I think God loves to hear:
“God, I hate that I hate them. I don’t have the strength to let go. So I’m asking you to do it in me.”
That’s not weak faith. That’s the first honest step out of the jail cell. And here’s the good news: the door was never locked from the outside. The King already paid for your release. You can walk out whenever you’re ready, and he will walk with you.
Let’s pray.